Review of For Sale

Review Summary
Comped Playtest Review
Written Review

February 4, 2009


by: Shannon Appelcline


Style: 4 (Classy & Well Done)
Substance: 5 (Excellent!)

A new edition of Stefan Dorra's excellent property auction game.

Shannon Appelcline has written 679 reviews (including 202 card game reviews), with average style of 4.03 and average substance of 3.85. The reviewer's previous review was of Money.

This review has been read 4951 times.

 
Product Summary
Name: For Sale
Publisher: Gryphon Games
Line: Gryphon Games Bookshelf
Author: Stefan Dorra
Category: Card Game

Cost: $24.95
Year: 2009



Review of For Sale
For Sale is a quick and simple auction game by Stefan Dorra, published as part of Gryphon Games' bookshelf series.
Players: 3-6
Time: 15 minutes

This is a revision of my review of the very similar edition of For Sale published by Uberplay four years previously.

The Components

For Sale comes in a small box with a deck of cards and a pack of "chips".

Cards: The cards are all medium-sturdy cards printed full-color on linen-textured card stock.

30 of the cards are Properties. Each one features a value from 1-30 and a picture of a real estate property. The artwork by Alvin Madden is delightful and evocative. We have, for example, a smelly box as the "1" property, a tent as the "7" property, a nice house as the "22" property, and a space station as the "30" property. This art adds a lot to the game and also make the cards easier to remember.

The other 30 cards are currencies. Each one shows a variety of icons along with a value from 2-15 or 0. (There are two of each.) Amusingly, these same style currency cards are used in High Society, another Gryphon Games bookshelf game, giving the line some nice consistency.

Chips: These are coins: 60 $1000 silver coins and 14 $2000 golden coins. They're printed on nice, linen-textured cardboard. Though they're the same size, the difference in color makes it easy to tell the denominations apart.

Rulebook: An short 4-page full-color rulebook. There aren't examples or explanatory illustrations, but the game is simple and thus still easy to explain.

Overall, the quality of all the components is high; they're easy to use, and the Alvin Madden artwork found on the property cards is entirely delightful. Thus For Sale earns a high "4" out of "5" for Style.

The Gameplay

In For Sale the object of the game is earn the most money through the clever purchase and sale of real estate.

Setup: Each of the two decks of cards is shuffled, and a couple of cards are taken out for 3-4 player games, so that they'll divide evenly. Each player is given $14-16 in chips (depending on the number of players).

Auctioning the Properties: The game starts off with auctioning all of the properties (from 24-30 cards, depending on the number of players).

For each auction a number of properties are laid out equal to the number of players. Starting with the first player (initially someone random, later whomever won the previous auction), each player either bids more on the properties than the previous bidder or passes. The bids continue going clockwise around the table until everyone but one player has passed.

If someone passes they take the lowest valued property still out, turn in half of their bid (rounded up), and then are out for the rest of the current round of bidding. If a person is the last bidder he must pay his whole bid, but gets the last property, which is clearly the best.

Thus, each player gets one property each round of play until all the properties have been auctioned off.

Auctioning the Checks: Now players sell the properties they purchased through a second set of auctions.

For each auction a number of currency cards are laid out, again equal to the number of players. Each player then takes one of their properties and places it face down. They're all revealed simultaneously, and the player with the most valuable property gets the top currency, the second gets the second, etc.

Again, each player gets one currency cards for each round of play (and expends one of their properties).

Ending the Game: The game ends after all the properties have been purchased then sold. Each player adds up the value of all their currency cards, then adds in any chips they had remaining from the first set of auctions. The player with the highest total wins.

Relationships to Other Games

For Sale was originally released in 1997 in Germany in a slightly different form. In 2005 the game was released in the United States by Uberplay. It made various changes to the gameplay, including supporting more players and changing how bids were made. This new edition by Gryphon largely follows the rules from the Uberplay edition. There's one difference that I'm aware of: you now round up what you lose in a bid rather than rounding down--but I suspect this is just correcting a typo from the Uberplay edition.

Even the components of the new Gryphon Games edition are nearly identical to the previous Uberplay edition, using the same artwork and approximately the same decisions for component manufacture. If you already own the Uberplay edition, you'd only want to pick this game up if you want to get the nice new numbered edition for your shelf.

For Sale is at core a simple auction game. It has two auction types, turn-based continuous open bidding (the real estate auction), and simultaneous one-time blind bidding (the check auction). Both systems are sufficiently interesting to keep the game hopping, and I particularly like the blind bidding round, mostly because it's one of the few blind-bidding auctions that really works well, primarily because of the discrete resources that players can bid with (1 of X cards).

This new edition of For Sale is also part of Gryphon Games' "bookshelf series" of games, all of which are high-quality and quick fillers. The other four games in this series released simultaneously with For Sale are Roll Through the Ages, Knizia's Gem Dealer, Money, and Knizia's High Society. Ironically, Money is one of the few other blind bidding games that I think really works.

The Game Design

For Sale is a short filler game, and by this criteria is succeeds very well. It is short (with the 15 minutes to play quoted above being very accurate) and simple to play (with explanations just taking 5 minutes). However, the auctions are also very solid, allowing real tactical thought, bluffing, and careful assessment of your opponents.

Balancing that is the fact that the game isn't too complex; instead the level of tactical thought lines up perfectly with the length of play. I don't want a really complex game when I'm only going to be playing for 15 minutes, and For Sale doesn't overchallenge (though counting cards would help a little).

I've had the good luck to get to try For Sale with every possible number of players, from 3-6, before writing this review. I'm happy to say that it works well with all of them. I think I'd be the happiest playing this with exactly four players, but I'd have no compunctions playing it with any of the valid player numbers. It's a little less exciting with 3, and when you get up to 6 it can get a little bit chaotic (because prices can get too high for you to bid in the open auction if an auction starts to your left), but the differences aren't that huge.

Overall, besides the fact that I've really enjoyed every game of For Sale that I've played (14 to date, most with my older Uberplay set), my best measure of success is that numerous players said that they wanted to buy copies after playing it.

For Sale is a great filler game. It's quick, it's fun, and it's even a little addictive. It's earns a full "5" out of "5" for Substance.

Conclusion

I'm extremely pleased that Gryphon Games has made this classic filler game available again. For me, it picks up several plays year after year. It's one of my favorite fillers because of its deft combination of short, simple play with significant tactical decisions. I highly recommend it.

Copyright © 1996-2014 Skotos Tech and individual authors, All Rights Reserved