I’m very pleased with the fantasy flavor of BattleLore – it helps set it apart from the other games in the Commands and Colors series (notably the Commands and Colors: Ancient version). Still, the medieval feel is strong, and I know that many want a more historical flavor for the game. Most of the expansion packs have focused on the fantasy, now one has come out that is more concerned with history.
The Hundred Years’ War – Crossbows and Polearms (Days of Wonder, 2007 – Richard Borg) is a double sized expansion pack for the basic game, adding in four new types of units, five scenarios, and rules of how to make the lore system work in a “historical” setting. Even though I could care less about the “no fantasy” rules, I still like having the extra units and options; and it is interesting to see how the system works with no magic. (Hint: it’s better with magic)
Let’s look at what the expansion pack includes (as a side note, I now have managed to put all four specialist packs and the epic expansion in the original box. I had to remove the plastic insert and barely get the lid on, so anything new coming is going to need another box.)
1.) Five new scenarios are added, the battles of Crecy, Poitiers, Cocherel, Patay, and Agincourt. Each battle makes use of the news weapons included with the game, also attempting to follow the historical battles that actually occurred during this long and pointless war. The battle of Agincourt is an “epic” one, requiring Epic BattleLore, but is by far my favorite and most interesting scenario in the game. It takes the famous battle and manages to do a neat job of pitting many longbow units against a huge foot soldier army. Terrific, epic stuff.
2.) Arbalesters: These allow the humans to have crossbows, which have a range of three hexes, but hit on a bonus strike. While useful, I normally wouldn’t pick them over the longbow, but the command cards that put them in the game add range where no range was or allow up to three of them to join. Nice, but the least exciting part of the set.
3.) Spearmen: We’ve seen these in the Goblin and Dwarf expansions, and they are the same here – allowing foot units to battle back with one extra die. The card allows two blue spear units to be placed in the game; and if they are bold, they can become devastating to the opponents.
4.) Halberdiers: But who cares about spears when you have halberds in the game! The card allows one red banner halberd unit to be added to the game, which hits on a bonus die – even against mounted units AND rolls an extra die when battling back. The ultimate defensive unit - they can stop the advances of normal cavalry, and you’ll find an army often including one of these in their forces. (And they work well in conjunction with a Dwarf army, by the way.)
5.) Hornblowers: By far the most unique figure in the army, the command card allows two hornblowers to be embedded in two different foot units. Two command cards are included, so that a player could field four of these chaps if they desire. The hornblower allows a unit to “call” an adjacent friendly unit to fight with it in battle. If the adjacent unit is also adjacent to the unit that the hornblower is attacking, the dice are combined for the attack. This allows extra dice, which is certainly nice; but it goes beyond that. If you compare it to two units attacking the same unit, one may make the attacked unit retreat before the second gets to hit it. This combines one large attack, and has a greater chance of destroying the attacked unit. Even better, dice can be combined when attacking terrain, finally budging some of those stubborn defensive units out.
6.) Components: The figures for all the new units look good; although the units are small enough that you may easily get them mixed up with the others. But no matter, as the banners clearly delineate what type of unit everything is.
7.) Medieval time: Rules are included to utilize lore in a historical battle. No War Council is used, and players don’t start with Lore tokens or counters. Players may hold a maximum of one card, can only get lore from rolling the dice, and must pay an extra three for every card used. Any Lore card that has magic in it is removed from the game before playing, which leaves out most of the Wizard’s and Cleric’s cards. These rules are certain to please those who want straight historical scenarios without the fantasy “nonsense”, but I don’t really want to use them much – I like the increased complexity and options magic brings.
Obviously those craving more accuracy and historical simulations will be the biggest seekers of this expansion. But even those, like myself, who simply want to increase the BattleLore universe will be happy with the expansion. The hornblowers and halberdiers can be put into any army – whether human, Goblin, or Dwarf – and the scenarios involved are fantastic! Probably my least favorite of the expansions so far – I want to see new and exotic creatures; it still has appeal to me as a history lover; and the Battle of Agincourt is truly a fascinating game.
Tom Vasel
“Real men play board games”
www.thedicetower.com
|
|
|
Help support RPGnet by purchasing this item through Gamer's Attic.
|
|
|
Please help support RPGnet by purchasing the following (probably) related items through DriveThruRPG.
|
|
|
|
Comped Playtest Review
Tom Vasel
October 31, 2007
Style: 4 (Classy & Well Done)
Substance: 4 (Meaty)
A historical version of BattleLore, with actual battles from the war included. New units are included, as well as ways to get rid of magic.
Tom Vasel has written 566 reviews, with average style of 3.47 and average substance of 3.39. The reviewer's previous review was of Cutthroat Caverns: Deeper and Darker. This review has been read 1849 times. |
|
|
Multiplayer Strategy:
|
|
Downloadable RPGs:
|
|
Visit our Sponsors!
|
|
