RPGnet
 
REVIEW OF BLOODY SEPTEMBER


Warning Shot

Bloody September isn’t literature, it’s a story. Trying to hone a review of a college-sized text written by multiple authors that’s not an anthology is doomed at the start; the hands form the story together, if disjointedly. The book is a case study of viewing fractured information coming into a news desk during a crisis or war, that is, the tone needs to match, but the voices are almost discordant.

Product Notes

Bloody September cover

White Wolf
launches its attacks on the Vampire: the Masquerade metaplot with this compilation volume of the Vampire Clan Novels. Bloody September offers a smattering of vampiric events, but doesn’t garner any points for its underdeveloped characters and action-dependant story arc. This book gets crosscutting down, but the uneven hand of multiple authors shows in this text.

Rating
6 out of 10:
3 for Style.
3 for Substance.


Bloody September review...
"... Despite her fanatical quest to examine her every action, she felt the horrifying certainty that all freedom was illusory, nothing more than ignorance. Like the blood within her undead body, her soul was not her own...” (p. 158, “Sunday, 8 August 1999, 11:59 PM.”)

Bloody September is the third volume in the four part Clan Novel Saga published by White Wolf as a way of getting several new readers into their (now-defunct) Vampire: the Masquerade fiction line, as well as those readers put off by a daunting fourteen part novel series. I was one such reader, so this review reflects a “new to the course of events” reading.

The characters in Bloody September come from the various Clans that make (or is that made) up the vampiric lineage that the setting proposes. The actions of these characters continues from the previous volumes, though the way they do it is often lackluster.

It’s a personal opinion that multi-authored works lack an intrinsic coherence that solo-authored works have, some times several styles adds to the enjoyment of the work, but in this case, it was hard to enjoy in places. The chronological chapters, while engaging, didn’t always flow from one point to another. Because as with a temporal change, an author change may have happened as well, undercutting the poise of one chapter versus another. I will say that the volume, overall, was well edited, but the change in authors some times pushed me back out of the story.

Don’t mistake Bloody September for a tale of longing and contemplation, it’s a oddly staged action story. The Clans of the Camarilla and Sabbat sects are now engaging each other openly in city streets, one Prince going so far as to use his immoral influence to call out the National Guard to enforce a curfew so that the battles won’t come to close to destroying his city.

Bloody September is a nice gaming related book, has lots of ways of interpreting the way the rules interact with a story. We get to see several uses of game powers (disciplines) and in-game jargon, like Prince, Sabbat, Ravnos, diablerie, etc. Luckily for those wanting to the know what the heck is being talked about, there’s a glossary in the back appendices to refer to.

Overall, Bloody September is a good Vampire story collection, though probably not the best in vampire fiction. The book is very game-keyed, so those looking for a good, general vampire story might look elsewhere. But those already sucked into the events unfolding (as this is the third volume of the story), you will be more than passingly familiar with the inconsistencies that creep up time and again.


PDF STORE: BUY THIS ITEM FROM DRIVETHRURPG

Help support RPGnet by purchasing this item through DriveThruRPG.

Clan Novel Saga, Volume 3: Bloody September (Novel)

PRODUCT SUMMARY

Name: Bloody September
Publisher: White Wolf
Line: Vampire: the Masquerade
Author: Weick, Stewart, Gherbod Fleming, Eric Griffin, with Kathleen Ryan, Justin Achilli, Richard Dansky; additional contributions by Lucien Soulban
Category: Book/Fiction

Cost: 17.99
Pages: 592
Year: 2004

SKU: WW11272
ISBN: 1-58846-853-4

View [ Printable Review ]


REVIEW SUMMARY

Comped Capsule Review
Alex deMorris
June 16, 2004

Style: 3 (Average)
Substance: 3 (Average)

Bloody September launches its attacks on the Vampire: the Masquerade metaplot with this compilation volume of the Vampire Clan Novels. The book offers a smattering of vampiric events, but doesn’t garner any points for its underdeveloped characters and action-dependant story arc. Bloody September gets crosscutting down, but the uneven hand of multiple authors shows in this text.

Alex deMorris has written 107 reviews (including 47 book/fiction reviews), with average style of 3.49 and average substance of 3.52. The reviewer's previous review was of Shadow Games.

This review has been read 3103 times.


RELATED REVIEWS
Archons and Templars
Black Hand Toreador antitribu Starter Deck
Clan book Lasombra Trilogy Book 1: Shards
Clan book Lasombra Trilogy Book 1: Shards
Clan Novel: Tremere
Clanbook Giovanni Revised
Clanbook: Assamite (Revised)
Clanbook: Assamite Revised
Clanbook: Followers of Set
Clanbook: Gangrel

Multiplayer Strategy:
Pox Nora

Downloadable RPGs:
DTRPG

Visit our Sponsors!

RECENT FORUM POSTS
Post TitleAuthorDate
RE: More substance,dude!RPGnet ReviewsJune 18, 2004 [ 05:02 am ]
RE: More substance,dude!RPGnet ReviewsJune 17, 2004 [ 10:45 pm ]
RE: More substance,dude!RPGnet ReviewsJune 17, 2004 [ 08:51 pm ]
RE: More substance,dude!RPGnet ReviewsJune 17, 2004 [ 04:22 pm ]
RE: More substance,dude!RPGnet ReviewsJune 17, 2004 [ 02:25 pm ]
RE: More substance,dude!RPGnet ReviewsJune 17, 2004 [ 05:44 am ]
RE: More substance,dude!RPGnet ReviewsJune 16, 2004 [ 11:05 pm ]
RE: More substance,dude!RPGnet ReviewsJune 16, 2004 [ 09:57 pm ]
More substance,dude!RPGnet ReviewsJune 16, 2004 [ 01:10 pm ]

[ Read FAQ | Subscribe to RSS | Partner Sites | Contact Us | Advertise with Us ]

Copyright © 1996-2008 Skotos & individual authors, All Rights Reserved
RPGnet® is a registered trademark of Skotos Tech Inc., all rights reserved.